The Blusher – Edibility, Identification, Distribution

Amanita rubescens

The Blusher

The Blusher

  • Edibility – 3/5 – Must be cooked. . I have no problem eating it well cooked in soups, stews, fried etc without the pre-boiling, but you should certainly start by following standard advice to chop, boil in salted water for up to 5 mins, discard water, rinse, then use as usual.
  • Identification – 1/5 – Despite being very easy to find, the blusher is not a beginners mushroom – never munch on a hunch! Identification for the table requires close observation. Key features of bulbous base, white ring on stipe, white gills, brown cap with white scales are not enough to be sure you have a blusher. A tendency for its white flesh to bruise pinkish-red when damaged should support your identification.  Be sure you do not have a Panther Cap (amanita pantherina) which does not have a grooved ring and does have a distinct rim (like an acorn cup) on its volva/base. The margin (cap edge) of blushers tend to be striated (finely grooved), while the panther cap has a smooth margin. The cap of the panther cap tends to be more reliably deep brown, though cap colour in all fungi, and especially amanitas, can change rapidly according to weather condition and age. Despite being very easy to find, the blusher is not a beginners mushroom – never munch on a hunch!
  • Distribution  – 5/5 – Very common indeed
  • Season: June – November
  • Habitat: most conifers and deciduous trees, but especially birch, beech, spruce and pine.

The blusher is one of the UK’s most common mushrooms, and certainly its most common edible fungi. Very few fungi forays fail to turn one up, usually dozens, often hundreds. So its something of a shame that its scary relatives (death cap, destroying angel, fly agaric, and especially panther cap, on account of it being a similar colour) mean its very rarely eaten by any other than the most confident mycophagists.

I have seen hundreds of thousands of blushers over my 30 or so years of fungi foraging (mostly in W Scotland) but never knowingly found a panther cap. The fact that I walk past so many blushers without going into close ID mode, might mean i’ve missed some panther caps down the years. But they are certainly not common in Scotland. I’d love to find one and acquaint myself more closely with it! They are powerful hallucinogens, seemingly beyond even the fly agaric, and while they have been used in shamanic rituals, and certainly aren’t quite so deadly as death caps and destroying angels, it would be very foolhardy to mess with panther caps recreationally!

Another barrier to eating blushers is their extreme susceptibility to fungal gnat larvae infestation. Like ceps, they can be riddled with wrigglers before they are even close to fully formed.

But I still can’t help thinking we are mostly missing out on an excellent food source here…

blusher button

Related Pages:

8 Comments

  • Chris Craig says:

    Are Blushers hallucinogenic?

  • Iain Connon says:

    Hi mark, is it ok to dry blushers and powder them without cooking?
    Regards, Iain

    • Mark Williams says:

      I guess you would be cooking the powder anyway, when you come to use it? That is probably advisable anyway. Mark.

  • Bork says:

    I am a bit confused regarding the edibility of A. rubescens. The local mycological society claims there is a difference between the specimens found in conifer woods as opposed to the ones found in deciduous/ broad leaf forests, and that they don’t recommend the conifer variety for the table. Yet, the reason why is not explained. I’m thinking because of toxins, but I can not find an iota of information on this subject anywhere else.

    • Mark Williams says:

      Hi Bork,
      I’ve never heard this information before. Maybe ask them if they have a source for it? And I’d be grateful if you shared it here if they do!
      Mark.

      • Bork says:

        Thank you for your answer, I appreciate it. First of all, I must correct myself, as the source
        of this information is indeed not the local mycological association, but from a site that
        provides a so-called “AI” mushroom identification service. I have mailed them, asking
        them for the source.

        I have been in contact with a few experienced mushroom hunters and a couple
        mycologists, and they have no references to the claims, and say that the current
        consensus is that there is one European red-staining Amanita, A. rubescens, and
        that it requires cooking for 10-15 minutes, regardless of its habitat.

        I’ll await an eventual reply, and post the results here.

  • Jym says:

    Hi Mark, I’m passionate about foraging, so you’re a man after my own heart. The Blusher is probably my favourite breakfast mushroom, due to its meaty texture – a perfect accompaniment to scrambled eggs and bacon! I always boil rapidly for 3 or 4 mins, then rinse well before patting dry and browning in a hot pan finished with butter. I always feel a bit guilty when collecting them though, because I usually use a paper bag to separate them from the ceps etc. – on account of their poisonous raw state – and thus prevent the dissemination of spores (though I would add that I don’t pick them often or in great numbers, and they’re locally prolific here in Fife).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *